Business Growth Consulting

Startup Consultant Role

In 2017 I paid a consultant $22,000 for a go-to-market strategy. We were six people with about fourteen months of runway, selling rostering software to aged care operators. What came back was a 70-slide deck. It had a TAM slide, three customer personas with stock-photo faces and a chart of “strategic pillars”. I read it on a Sunday and felt good for about a day. Then we went back to doing exactly what we’d been doing.

The company was gone by 2019. The deck wasn’t the reason, but it didn’t help. That 22 grand was nearly two months of a developer.

I’m on my second company now. It’s freight software, with 22 staff and a seed round and a bridge behind us. I’ve used consultants a lot more this time, and mostly they’ve been worth it. A couple were worth ten times what we paid. So this isn’t an anti-consultant rant. It’s what I wish someone had told me about where consultants in startups actually earn their fee, and where you’re just paying to feel like you’re making progress.

Startup consultant

Who’s calling themselves a consultant

Pretty much anyone. That’s the first problem.

In one week of LinkedIn requests I got:

  • an ex-Big Four strategy manager
  • a former founder who’d sold a payroll business and now helps a few companies
  • a fractional CFO
  • an R&D tax firm
  • a growth marketer charging $8k a month
  • someone whose headline said “Helping founders unlock their next level”

Those are not the same job. Lump them all together as “consultants” and you’ll hire the wrong one.

The useful ones bring something you haven’t got and can’t build fast enough. Usually they’ve done the specific thing before, more than once, and can see the hole you’re about to step in. Sometimes it’s a network. Sometimes they just don’t love your product the way you do, so they’ll say the obvious thing nobody inside the company will.

None of them should be making your decisions for you.

Pay for things that work, not for documents

Every founder has heard about strategy versus execution. Most still pay for the wrong one.

At seed stage, your strategy is rarely the problem. You know you need more paying customers, a sharper pitch and enough runway to raise again. What you don’t know is how to build a sales pipeline that doesn’t leak. You also don’t know how to build a model that survives an associate poking at your churn assumption. A strategy consultant will write that you need those things. Cool. You knew that already.

My test now is simple: what do I have at the end? If the answer is a document, I’m wary. If it’s a CRM with stages that mean something, or a board pack I can produce every month without help, that’s money well spent.

Proper strategy work has its place. Maybe you’re deciding whether to expand into New Zealand or the UK, or whether to move upmarket into enterprise. That’s later, when a wrong call costs you a year. Before then, put the money on someone who’ll get their hands dirty.

Generalists early, specialists when it gets expensive

For the first eighteen months, everything’s on fire and you can’t tell which fire matters. A good generalist helps here. By good, I mean someone who’s actually run a company, not someone who’s advised on running one.

Ours was a woman who’d built and sold a logistics business in Brisbane. We met for coffee once a month, and she was paid in a small equity grant. In the first meeting, she picked up that my co-founder and I had different ideas about the business. One of us thought we were building a product. The other thought we were running a services business. We’d been arguing about it sideways for months without ever naming it.

Specialists are for narrow problems where a mistake is expensive and hard to undo:

  • R&D Tax Incentive claims
  • employee share schemes and the startup tax concession, which are fiddly and painful to fix later
  • financial models before a raise
  • anything regulated, like TGA approval, an AFSL, health data or privacy

Be careful with R&D tax consultants

This is the one I’d watch hardest. Lots of these firms work on contingency, often 15 to 30 per cent of the refund. That’s fine if the work’s solid. The problem is the incentive. A bigger claim means a bigger fee for them.

When AusIndustry or the ATO reviews the claim two years later, the consultant isn’t the one paying it back. You are. A mate of mine had part of a claim knocked back and had to repay it in the middle of a raise.

Ask any R&D firm to walk you through how they’d defend your claim, activity by activity. If they go vague, walk away.

Where I’d actually spend the money

Before you’ve raised

Mostly you need the boring foundations. That means company structure, founder vesting, a decent shareholders agreement and Xero set up properly. Plenty of that is a lawyer’s or an accountant’s job. A good adviser will tell you so. A bad one will have a crack at your shareholders agreement themselves.

The other thing worth paying for is time with someone who knows your customer’s world. Before we built anything this time, I paid a retired operations manager from a mid-sized transport company for three half-days. He killed two features I was sure about. He also told me dispatchers would never use anything that needed more than one hand. It was the cheapest product research we’ve ever done.

Getting ready to raise

This is where our fractional CFO earned her keep. She worked two days a month. She rebuilt our model, made us cut our year-two revenue forecast by a third and set up the data room.

In our first partner meeting, the investor went straight for gross margin and payback on acquisition cost. We had answers. Six months earlier, that meeting would have gone very differently.

I wouldn’t pay anyone offering to “raise for you” on a success fee. Most Australian VCs don’t want a slice of their cheque going to a middleman, and some won’t touch a deal that involves one. There can also be licensing issues around who’s allowed to arrange investment. Get legal advice before you sign anything like that. Investors want to meet you, not your intro guy.

When operations start falling over

Somewhere around 12 to 25 people, stuff starts to break. Leave balances are wrong. Nobody knows who can approve a $4,000 spend. Sales numbers live across three spreadsheets and a Slack channel.

We brought in a fractional ops person for about four months. She didn’t do anything clever. She wrote down how things actually worked, fixed what was broken and handed it all to our office manager. It was exactly what we needed. It cost maybe a quarter of a full-time hire we couldn’t have afforded anyway.

Go-to-market, where the money goes to die

Most of the money I’ve wasted on consultants went here. Technical founders hate sales, so we pay someone to make it go away. It doesn’t go away.

Early go-to-market isn’t about brand. It’s about finding which channel works and what message gets the right buyer to reply. Good GTM people want to listen to your sales calls, read through your lost deals and run small, cheap tests. Bad ones want to start with your positioning and a new logo.

If someone’s opening proposal includes a “brand workshop” and you’ve got 30 customers, that tells you plenty.

When to keep your wallet shut

Don’t hire a consultant to tell you what your business is. That’s your job. If you outsource it, an investor will find out you don’t know the answer.

Don’t hire one to make a decision you’re dodging, either. Firing a co-founder and killing a product line are good examples. They’ll give you a framework, and you’ll still have to make the call.

And do the runway maths. If a fee takes more than about a month off your runway and the problem isn’t urgent, it can wait. An accelerator mentor telling you to “get some advice” doesn’t make it urgent.

The dependency trap

I’ve watched this go badly a few times. A founder can’t explain their own financial model because someone else built it. An investor works that out in about ten minutes. The meeting’s over at that point, even if it runs another forty.

There’s a slower version too. Some consultants are very good at becoming permanent. Each project rolls into the next, and you never quite learn to do the work yourself. Eighteen months later you’re paying $6k a month for what’s basically a phone call.

We had one of those. He was a nice bloke and smart. I kept him on about a year longer than I should have because letting him go felt awkward. That’s on me, not him.

Also remember who wears the consequences. If the advice is wrong, the consultant moves on to the next client. You’re the one standing in front of the board and the team.

Before you sign anything

Ask whether they’ve done the thing. Advising on it doesn’t count. If they’re helping with your raise, have they raised money or written cheques? If it’s sales, have they ever carried a number?

Go around their references. The Aussie startup scene is small. Three messages to people in your network will tell you more than any testimonial page.

Get a tight scope. You want an outcome, a timeframe and a fixed fee or capped hours. “Ongoing strategic support” with no deliverable is how you end up paying for coffees.

Ask about a job that went wrong. Everyone with real experience has one. If they can’t think of any, or it was entirely the founder’s fault, that’s your answer.

Watch how they treat your cash. The best adviser I’ve had told me twice not to hire her, because we could do the job ourselves. I trust her completely because of it.

What I’d tell myself in 2017

Hire for one specific problem. Make sure the person has done it with their own skin in the game. Come out the other end with something that works, not something to read. And keep the thinking inside the company, so the knowledge doesn’t walk out the door when the consultant does.

Next time you’re about to sign with someone, write one sentence about what will be different when they’re finished. If you can’t write that sentence, don’t sign yet.

Please follow and like us:
Pin Share